Pros and Cons of Section 8 Tenants: A Guide for Charlotte Landlords

Pros and Cons of Section 8 Tenants: A Guide for Charlotte Landlords

Asking rents were up 3.5% in February 2025 compared to the same time last year, according to Zillow's latest rental report. For Charlotte landlords, this market pressure creates both challenges and opportunities -- especially when considering Section 8 tenants. With housing affordability concerns mounting, many property owners find themselves wondering: is participating in the Housing Choice Voucher program worth it?

As property management experts serving Charlotte's diverse rental market, we've seen firsthand how Section 8 can significantly impact landlord experiences -- both positively and negatively. Before deciding whether to open your doors to tenants, understanding the complete picture is essential for protecting your investment while potentially tapping into a steady income stream that many landlords overlook. Read on for important Section 8 tenant rental strategies.

What Is Section 8 Housing?

The Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher Program provides financial assistance to low-income families, seniors, and individuals with disabilities, making it easier for them to afford rental housing in the private market. Under the program, the government pays a portion of the tenant's rent directly to landlords, while tenants contribute the remaining amount (typically 30% of their adjusted income).

To participate, landlords must maintain properties that meet Housing and Urban Development (HUD) standards, including passing annual property inspections. These inspections ensure that the housing remains safe, sanitary, and in good repair for tenants.

Pro: Guaranteed Rental Income

Perhaps the most compelling benefit of accepting Section 8 tenants is the reliable income stream. The government portion of rent arrives consistently each month, reducing concerns about late or missed payments. In uncertain economic times, this guaranteed income provides valuable stability for your investment.

Pro: Reduced Vacancy Rates

With Charlotte's affordable housing shortage, Section 8 properties rarely sit empty for long. When you list a property as Section 8-approved, you'll typically see significant interest from qualified applicants, minimizing costly vacancy periods.

Pro: Longer Tenancy

Section 8 tenants tend to stay longer in their rental homes. Once they find a suitable property, many remain for years due to limited affordable housing options and the desire to maintain their voucher benefits. This reduced turnover saves you time and money on finding new tenants.

Pro: Simplified Tenant Screening

Public Housing Agencies maintain lists of eligible Section 8 participants who have already been screened for program eligibility. This pre-screening can streamline your tenant selection process, though you should still conduct your standard background checks.

Con: Administrative Challenges

The Section 8 program involves significant paperwork and administrative requirements. Initial approval can take weeks, and payment delays sometimes occur during the setup process. Be prepared for longer turnaround times compared to conventional rentals.

Con: Limited Control Over Rent Pricing

HUD establishes Fair Market Rent values for Charlotte neighborhoods, capping what you can charge Section 8 tenants. These limits might be lower than what you could achieve with non-subsidized renters, especially in appreciating areas.

Is Section 8 Right for Your Charlotte Property?

The Section 8 program offers both significant advantages and challenges for Charlotte landlords. Landlord decision making should ultimately be guided by your property investment goals, property location, and management approach. As a locally-owned office, PMI Mecklenburg has helped countless landlords navigate the Section 8 program successfully. Our team understands the Charlotte market and works closely with Section 8 tenants to ensure a smooth rental experience.

Discover how our property management insights can help maximize your rental returns while providing quality housing for our community.

back